GOP ObamaCare fight faces do-or-die procedural vote
A CBO score that found the legislation would leave 22 million more people without insurance in the next decade has raised the stakes on a procedural vote that could come as soon as Tuesday.
At least four Republicans say they may vote against their party on the motion to proceed, underscoring the opposition to McConnell’s bill.
The defectors include centrist Sen. Susan Collins (Maine), who panned the bill on Twitter Monday evening; fellow moderate Sen. Dean Heller (R-Nev.); and two conservatives, Sens. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) and Ron Johnson (R-Wis.).
McConnell can only afford two defections.
A loss on the procedural vote would certainly end work on the measure this week, and it could be a brutal blow to getting the legislation through the Senate on a later time frame.
Despite the uphill climb, McConnell’s lieutenants on Monday voiced optimism.
“I’m very optimistic, yes,” Senate Republican Whip John Cornyn (R-Texas) told reporters when asked if he still stood by his guarantee from a week ago that the legislation would muster 50 votes.
But Cornyn isn’t saying when the vote will take place.
If GOP leaders can wrangle the votes, it will happen Tuesday. If they can’t get it Tuesday, they will try for Wednesday.
And if that doesn’t work, it may get pushed to beyond the July 4 recess, which would give opponents time to pressure GOP senators over the holiday break.
“We may not know if we have the votes to pass it until we bring it up,” said Senate Republican Conference Chairman John Thune (R-S.D.), the third-ranking member of the GOP leadership.
Rank-and-file Republican senators realize that they have limited time to further mold the legislation and once the motion to proceed passes, kicking off 20 hours of debate and a flurry of amendments in the Senate’s vote-a-rama process, the proceedings will become harried and hectic.
GOP leaders are confident the rebels will come around if given the right concessions – or at least the chance to claim a victory to constituents back home.
Paul is the only senator who’s viewed as a certain no.
He has said for months that he does not support creating a new system of tax credits to funnel federal dollars to insurance companies to help low-income people buy insurance. He argues this would set up a new entitlement that he calls “ObamaCare Lite.”
The junior Kentucky senator hopes to broker a deal to repeal parts of ObamaCare that all Republicans agree should go, even if they make up a small part of the controversial deal.
The other lawmakers are considered in play, despite their posturing in the days ahead of key floor votes.
John Weaver, a Republican strategist and former senior advisor to Ohio Gov. John Kasich (R), who opposes the Senate bill, said it would be very difficult for conservatives to kill the legislation — especially on a procedural vote.
Johnson, Lee and Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) are demanding regulatory reforms for their votes, which risks upsetting the political balance that has kept moderates on board so far.
But conservatives would face a backlash if they blowup the ObamaCare repeal and replace effort, Weaver said.
“Their demands are tougher to meet but the political pressure on them to support it is greater. I think that’s why they’ll support it,” he said.
One Republican source close to McConnell noted that Johnson ran for office as a long-shot Tea Party candidate in 2010 in response to the conservative outcry over ObamaCare.
“Ron Johnson ran for political office to repeal ObamaCare. I can’t believe he won a second term to prevent that from happening,” said the source.
Another group of Republicans, Sens. Rob Portman (R-Ohio), Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.) and Cory Gardner (R-Colo.), are worried about phasing out generous federal funding of expanded Medicaid enrollment. They met with leaders in McConnell’s Capitol office Monday evening to extract last-minute changes.
“Just continue to talk about ways that we can assure that we’re bringing down costs and understand the analysis that’s going to show that,” Gardner said after the meeting.
Placating moderates such as Collins, Heller, Portman and Capito could come down to guaranteeing resources for constituents who face the biggest potential impact, such as people who rely on Medicaid to treat opioid addiction.
While the Congressional Budget Office score released Monday projected that there would be 22 million more people without insurance by 2026 because of the legislation, it contained some good news, too.
The score estimated that premiums, a major concern of Johnson and other GOP critics, would lower average premiums after 2020 relative to projections under current law.
It also projected the bill would reduce the federal deficit by $321 billion over the next decade, considerably more than the House version.
That gives McConnell room to make concessions to wavering moderates in the form of extra spending for constituents who could be hardest hit, such as low-income seniors in rural areas or families struggling with opioid addiction.
“I think we’ll have some additional work to do,” Sen. John Thune (R-S.D.) told reporters, noting “there’s enough excess revenue” above the House bill to make significant concessions.